4 Common Social Media Mistakes Lawyers Make and How to Avoid Them

4 Common Social Media Mistakes Lawyers Make and How to Avoid Them

In today’s competitive legal landscape, having a strong social media presence is essential for law firms. Social media allows attorneys to build and maintain client relationships, establish their expertise, and attract new prospects. However, many law firms make critical mistakes when it comes to social media marketing. These errors often stem from misconceptions or a lack of clear strategy.

At Law Firm Mentor, we’ve helped countless law firms avoid these common pitfalls and leverage social media as a powerful marketing tool. In this blog, we’ll break down the four most common mistakes lawyers make with social media and provide tips on how to avoid them.

4 Common Social Media Mistakes Lawyers Make and How to Avoid Them

1. Focusing on Vanity Metrics Over Client Engagement

One of the biggest mistakes lawyers make with social media is placing too much emphasis on vanity metrics—likes, shares, and followers. While these metrics can be indicators of visibility, they don’t necessarily lead to more clients. Vanity metrics are often superficial and don’t reflect meaningful engagement with potential clients or referral sources.

Instead, focus on creating content that nurtures your relationships with previous clients and referral partners. Why? Because staying top-of-mind with your existing network can lead to repeat business and referrals.

Your social media strategy should focus on these key goals:

  • Referrals: Clients may refer others to you, and potential clients will often check your social media presence before contacting you.
  • Client Retention: Maintaining a presence on social media helps keep you at the forefront of your previous clients’ minds.
  • Credibility: Even if you have few followers, a well-maintained and professional social media profile can enhance your credibility.

Instead of focusing on follower count, aim to provide value through informative and helpful content.

Learn more about how to build strong client relationships in our How to Keep Your Firm Top of Mind.

2. Posting the Wrong Type of Content

Another common mistake is posting content that doesn’t resonate with your audience. Many lawyers mistakenly share viral trends or humorous content, believing that it will increase engagement. While this may result in more likes, it’s unlikely to help you build authority or attract clients.

Potential clients turn to attorneys for guidance and solutions, not for entertainment. That’s why your content should primarily focus on being educational and informative. Share blog posts, answer common legal questions, and provide updates on changes in the law. This type of content builds trust and positions you as an authority in your practice area.

Example: If you have business clients, think about informing them of new labor and employment rules.. “What do the new rules on non-competes mean for you?

For more tips on how to engage your audience effectively, check out our post on Marketing Consistency.

3. Underestimating the Time Commitment

Many attorneys underestimate the amount of time and effort it takes to maintain a consistent social media presence. Social media isn’t something you can dip into once in a while—it requires regular posting to keep your audience engaged. Ideally, you should aim to post once a day during the business week.

The good news is that with proper planning, you can schedule content in advance. Using social media management tools like Hootsuite or Buffer, you can batch-create posts and automate your content distribution. Consistency is crucial because it ensures your firm stays visible and relevant.

At Law Firm Mentor, we offer comprehensive Social Media Marketing Services designed to help law firms streamline their social media efforts, maximize visibility, and stay connected with their audience without spending hours managing accounts.

Discover how you can enhance your efficiency with automated marketing tools by reading our Systematize Your Law Firm Marketing.ailing to capture potential clients’ information when they visit their website. If someone lands on your site and leaves without providing their email address or phone number, you may have lost them forever. The solution? A compelling lead magnet.

A lead magnet is a free resource that you offer in exchange for a visitor’s contact information. For example, you could offer a free guide on “What to Expect in Your Divorce Process” or “5 Things to Know Before Hiring a Personal Injury Lawyer.” These types of guides are valuable to your prospective clients, helping them feel more confident and informed—and positioning your firm as the trusted source for legal help.

Once you have their information, you can nurture these leads through email campaigns, offering more valuable insights and encouraging them to schedule a consultation. This step turns website visitors into viable prospects who are more likely to become clients.

Check out how lead magnets can help your law firm generate more leads.

4. Not Having Clear Objectives for Social Media

Before you dive into social media marketing, it’s important to establish clear objectives. Many attorneys start posting without a strategy, which can lead to frustration and wasted effort. Define what you want to achieve: Do you want to generate new leads, maintain relationships with past clients, or strengthen your referral network?

Setting clear goals will guide your social media efforts and help you track your progress. For most law firms, social media should focus on staying visible to past clients, offering valuable content, and building trust within your network. It’s not about amassing followers but about positioning your firm as a reliable and knowledgeable resource.

Our team at Law Firm Mentor can help you define clear, measurable objectives for your firm’s social media strategy. Check out our Marketing Strategy Services to get started with a custom plan that fits your firm’s goals.

Learn more about setting marketing goals in our article Goals and Metrics for Your Law Firm’s Growth.

Make Social Media Work for Your Firm

Social media can be an effective tool for law firms, but only when used with a clear strategy. By avoiding these common mistakes—focusing on vanity metrics, posting irrelevant content, underestimating the time commitment, and lacking clear goals—you can build a strong social media presence that attracts clients, retains past clients, and strengthens referral relationships.

Ready to take your law firm’s marketing to the next level? At Law Firm Mentor, we specialize in helping law firms like yours grow through effective marketing strategies. Contact us today to learn how we can help you leverage social media and other digital marketing channels to boost your firm’s success.

Internal Link: Reach out to us for a consultation by visiting our Contact Us page.

Backlink Opportunities:

  • American Bar Association’s Social Media Marketing Guidelines
  • Justia Lawyer Directory
  • FindLaw’s Social Media Marketing Guide for Lawyers

By focusing on the right goals and avoiding these mistakes, your firm can build a robust and meaningful social media presence that drives real business growth.

Want to dive into more detail about how to help employees overcome law firm PTSD?

Check out this episode of the Crushing Chaos with Law Firm Mentor podcast.

Looking for guidance and support? Schedule a no-pressure, 15-minute call with our growth strategist and let’s talk.